Why don't they respond to cold emails?

In order of influence: the letter went to the wrong person, the subject did not force anyone to open it, the first two lines are about the sender, not the recipient, and at the end there is a request that requires a solution. The text in the middle of the letter has the least impact, although this is usually what is rewritten.

What should the subject line of a cold email be?

It looks like a letter from a person, not a newsletter: short, without caps, without exclamation marks and without promises of benefits. A subject line that looks like marketing sends the email to ignore before it is even opened.

What should I write in the first two lines?

Something that applies to the recipient, not to you. The first two sentences are visible in the preview, and if it says “we are a company that has been established since 2015,” the letter is closed without opening. Your company name can wait until the middle.

What counts as true personalization?

Specifics that cannot be substituted en masse: a link to a specific solution in their product, to a recent change, to a publication by their employee. Mentioning an industry or city is not personalization—it is variable substitution.

What should you ask for at the end of the letter?

Something that can be answered in one word. Asking for a meeting requires a decision and a calendar, so it loses to a question like “do you have it arranged this way or that way?” The answer to the question already opens the correspondence, and a meeting is proposed by a second letter.

How many times can you remind yourself?

Once, after a few working days, with a new argument, and not with the phrase “I’m raising the letter.” The second and third reminders add almost no replies, but turn the sender into a source of irritation.

How many emails do you need to send to understand if the scheme is working?

A few dozen in one segment are enough. If out of thirty letters to the correct segment there is not a single response, the problem is systemic - in the list or in the first lines - and increasing the volume will not solve it.

All articles

StrategySeptember 5, 20269 min

Cold emails: nine reasons why they aren't answered

Cold emails fail not because of the text, but because of the list and the first two lines. I'll look at nine reasons for silence in order of their influence: from the wrong addressee and subject of the letter to a request that cannot be answered in one word.

When cold mailing doesn't work, the text is rewritten. Almost always - the wrong part of it. The influence on the answer is unevenly distributed, and the middle of the letter is last on this list.

A correct person with a mediocre letter answers more often than an incorrect person with a perfect one. Everything else is details within this fact.

1. Order of influence

What	What does it affect?	How often do they repair
Mailing list	Is there any chance at all?	rarely
Subject of the letter	Will they open or not?	sometimes
First two lines	Finish reading or close	rarely
Request at the end	Will they answer or postpone?	almost never
Text in the middle	Least of all	always

The right column explains why mailings are not repaired. They work with what is easier to edit, and not with what solves it.

2. List: the wrong person

The most common and most invisible mistake. The letter about the tool for the sales department is sent to the general address of the company. Marketing proposal - to the CEO who receives a hundred emails a day.

The check is simple: the person you are writing to must have the problem you are solving and the authority to do something about it. If one of the two is missing, there will be no answer regardless of the text.

The second layer of the same error is that the company does not fit the profile. Thirty letters to the right segment yield more than three hundred to a random one, and are cheaper.

3. Subject: looks like a newsletter

The subject decides whether the email will be opened and is recognized in a split second. The signs by which an email is marked as mass mail are simple: caps, exclamation marks, promise of benefits, the word “offer,” emoji.

The work topic looks like it was written by a person to a specific person: short, unadorned, to the point. Sometimes it's just a question.

4. The first two lines: about you, not about them

In the email client preview, two or three sentences are visible. This is the real beginning of the letter - what makes the decision to open it.

The classic opening “My name is, I represent the company, we have been in business since 2015” wastes this space on information that the recipient does not yet need. The company name and job title live beautifully in the middle of the letter and in the signature.

What should be in the first lines: what relates to the recipient. An observation, a question, specifics about their situation.

5. Personalization that doesn't exist

“I noticed that you work in logistics” is not personalization, but variable substitution. The recipient sees this: such an offer can be sent to a thousand companies by changing one word.

What works is something that cannot be obtained en masse: a link to a specific solution in their product, to a recent change they made, to a publication by their employee. One such detail is worth more than the rest of the text.

Downside: True personalization doesn't scale. This is not a disadvantage, but a condition - and it determines the reasonable volume of the mailing.

6. A request that cannot be answered quickly

“When is it convenient for you to call for 30 minutes?” requires a person to make a decision, evaluate priority and open the calendar. This is a big request for the first contact, and it is put off - and the put off letter is not returned.

The question at hand is one that can be answered in one word: is this organized for you one way or another, is this task even relevant, who is doing it for you.

The answer to such a question is correspondence. A meeting is proposed by a second letter when the dialogue has begun.

7. Followup: one

One reminder in a few business days. Definitely with new content: not “raising the letter,” but a new argument, a different angle, a short example.

The second and third reminders add almost no responses and reliably spoil the impression. Silence after the first followup is an answer and worth accepting.

8. Length and format

The letter is read from the phone. Five short paragraphs are easy to read, but continuous text on the screen is not.

A practical guideline is one hundred to one hundred thirty words. Anything that doesn’t fit is usually a story about yourself and is removed without loss of meaning.

Ready-made texts for five segments - in cold email script template: there are also email subjects and followup structure.

9. How to understand that the problem is not in the text

Send thirty emails to one narrow segment. If there is no answer, the problem is systemic: the list or the first lines. Increasing the volume will not solve it, but will only multiply it.

If there are answers, but few, then it makes sense to work with formulations. And still start with the topic and the first two lines, and not from the middle.

10. Summary

List, topic, first two lines, request. In this order. The text in the middle of the letter is the first to be repaired and has the least impact.

The most underrated edit is to replace the request for a meeting with a question that requires one word in response. It costs nothing and changes the response rate more noticeably than rewriting the entire letter.